There are bands that evolve over the years, and there are those that simply keep proving why they gained the audience they have. Mob Rules clearly belong to the second category. “Stories From The Verdant Vale” does not attempt to turn things upside down or present a different side of the band. Instead, it firmly follows the familiar paths of melodic power metal and offers a collection of songs characterized by melody, energy and a strong epic feeling. From the very first notes, it becomes clear that the Germans know their formula very well. The guitars play a leading role, the melodies are carefully crafted, and the choruses have that characteristic feeling that makes you keep singing them to yourself after the song ends. “Master Of The Black Crow” stands out for its energy, while “Above The Maelstrom” slows things down and adds a more emotional dimension. That, however, is also where the album’s main weakness lies. Mob Rules do not really try to step outside their comfort zone. For those looking for experimentation or something genuinely new, the album probably will not offer many surprises. For loyal fans, though, this consistency is more of an advantage than a weakness. The second half of the record, featuring older material and different versions, works more as a bonus for collectors than as an essential part of the release. In the end, “Stories From The Verdant Vale” is not an album that will change the history of European power metal. It is, however, an honest, well-played and quality record from a band that still knows how to write melodies with substance.
♦ 8/10
Frost and Fire
